Industry opinions on UK digital ID scheme
The new digital ID scheme will help combat illegal working while making it easier for people to use vital government services. The government announced that digital ID will be mandatory for Right to Work (RTW) checks by the end of the Parliament.
However, there will be no requirement for individuals to carry their ID or be asked to produce it, said the government statement, “but digital ID will be mandatory as a means of proving your Right to Work”.
Responding to the news, the Recruitment & Employment Confederation (REC) CEO Neil Carberry said: “We use digital ID every day, from paying on our phones to travel and event tickets. There is no reason that the state should fall behind.
“By providing ID documents it already supplies digitally, the government can unlock faster job starts, and lower administration burdens in our labour market – as well as a faster, more accurate benefits system. This gives us a more fluent and dynamic job market – just what you need to achieve economic growth.
“This is a significant blocker to smooth, and efficient hiring for many APSCo members. APSCo has been asking government since before Covid to put in place a workable alternative to face-to-face engagement with original paper documents. A digital ID could make a big difference to all pre-employment/engagement ID and safeguarding checks.”
Keith Rosser, director at Reed Screening and advisory board member of the UK’s Better Hiring Institute, is confident a streamlined, data-driven hiring process would dramatically reduce time-to-hire. “We believe firms could hire someone in 10 days, compared to the current average of 44.
“People would start earning – and paying taxes – sooner, and productivity would improve because companies wouldn’t be sitting on unfilled vacancies. It affects everything. You could even see a reduction in hospital waiting lists because the NHS would be able to source people immediately.”
However, there are concerns regarding the government’s aim of helping to reduce illegal working. Oliver O’Sullivan, director of immigration at immigration law firm Migrate UK, says: “It’s interesting that the UK government are looking to reintroduce an ID card proposal given the overwhelming opposition to these cards in the past. Framing them in the context of preventing illegal workers doesn’t fully address issues that most people held previously with civil liberty.
“Illegal working is often the result of employers who don’t check right to work, or don’t know how to do it correctly. Will digital ID cards reduce illegal working? Not if the main reason for illegal working is employers knowingly hiring a person without permission to work or not doing the right checks in the first place. Right to work checks aren’t failing because of the documents involved.”
And Rob Jardin, chief digital officer at cybersecurity experts NymVPN, raises concerns regarding the risk of the system being breached, as well as the ability for those intent on breaking the law circumnavigating the digital protections.
“The prime minister argues digital IDs will help tackle illegal working – but in practice, people intent on breaking the rules usually find ways around ID checks.”
Final Thoughts - What to Watch Going Forward
How will the government define mandatory vs optional digital ID use‑cases (e.g., Right to Work, benefits, health, travel)?
Will the market remain open for private providers, or will state‑led wallet dominate?
How will accreditation/trust frameworks evolve (e.g., the DIATF issues)?
What safeguards are put in place for data security, digital exclusion, liability (if fraudulent ID is used)?
How quickly will industry adoption proceed (currently uptake is slow due to hesitation) and what will be the impact on recruiting tech talent?






